Senator Chris Murphy remains an enigma shrouded in contradictions.

Yesterday, Murphy’s unceasing fundraising for his re-election campaign included a text message to donors and potential donors that emphasized the Democrat’s mighty struggle. “Challenging the status quo — whether it’s the gun lobby, big oil or foreign policy establishment — comes with a price, and the only way a grassroots campaign like ours will be ready for whatever comes our way is with support from people like you,” wrote the two term U.S. Senator.

The highlights of his self-advertisements on the lonely life of an outsider include his friendship with the prime minister of Qatar, the autocratic nation that hosts Hamas leaders. The scars one must endure as the champion of the Houthis battling the establishment to keep them from being designated terrorists.

Who wouldn’t want to “pitch in” to help the friend of the Houthis? Their motto remains,”God is Great, Death to America, Death to Israel, A curse upon the Jews, Victory to Islam.”

Murphy’s assessment of Connecticut politics leaves no room for the spirit of rebellion. On Friday, he found time to support felonious Bridgeport Mayor Joseph Ganim in the run-up to Tuesday’s special election for mayor. The election is necessary because Ganim supporters engaged in such widespread absentee shenanigans last summer that the outcome could not be determined.

Supporting Ganim is the opposite of “challenging the status quo.”

Anyone who campaigns for Ganim in the aftermath of last fall’s absentee ballot trial forfeits his credibility in delivering homilies on how we are to uphold our democratic norms in this perilous hour for freedom under the rule of law.

Published February 23, 2024.

Democrat Nick Simmons launched his campaign for the 36th Senate District seat with a homey almost subdued video. The seat, which includes all of Greenwich and parts of Stamford and New Canaan. It is currently held by Republican Ryan Fazio.

Simmons will need to get by fellow Greenwich Democrat Trevor Crow. The life coach lost her 2022 campaign against Fazio by 89 votes in her first bid for public office. Crow began her 2024 campaign by inadvertently announcing at a Greenwich Democratic Town Committee meeting that she’d violated the state’s campaign finance laws.

Greenwich is no longer a reliable Republican bastion. Along with many affluent suburbs across the nation, it has delivered growing majorities for Democrats in state and national elections since Donald Trump became the face of the Republican Party. Fazio lost a competitive race for the 36th District seat in 2020 when he challenged first term Democrat Alexandra Kasser. He won a special election in 2021 after Kasser resigned.

Fred Camillo, Greenwich’s Republican first selectman in his third term, won a thumping victory in November, a year after Democrats claimed the tony town’s three House seats. March brings Republican town committee primaries that reflect the growing fractions in a party in decline and riven with ideological differences and suspicions.

Simmons is the brother of Stamford’s Democratic mayor, Caroline Simmons. She ought to have some influence in delivering convention delegates to her brother, though she’s had some ongoing tussles with the local party committee.

Nick Simmons left his position in Governor Ned Lamont’s office earlier this month.

Published February 22, 2024.

The conspirators have rewarded one of their own. John Healey has returned to the deeply divided dozen member Senate Republican caucus.

Johnny Angel, as he was known when he former House Minority Leader Lawrence Cafero’s aide who delivered $10,000 in cash to an FBI plant, will serve as chief of staff to state Senator Stephen Harding, who gulps from the poison chalice. Harding was the face of the tiny revolution that ousted Senator Kevin Kelly as leader of the shrinking Republic caucus.

Healey replaces Gary DeFilippo, who Kelly picked to replace Healy days before the 2024 regular session of the legislature began on February 7th. Daily Ructions understands another branch of government was considering providing a safe harbor to Healey had the coup failed or Harding suddenly become a better judge of conduct, including his own.

Harding will need to remember that in the dark business of treachery if they will do it for you, they will do it to you.

Published February 20, 2024.

State Senator Stephen Harding (R-30) began the day vowing tough questions would be asked at Tuesday’s Appropriation Committee hearing on higher education. He even provided a preview.

Harding was quoted at length in a Tuesday morning statement issued shortly before the hearing began:

“There are many questions that demand answers. With regard to the Office of Higher Education, for example, why were former Stone Academy students told to sign a waiver of their rights against the State of Connecticut in exchange for payment of just a small fraction of the damages they incurred?”  

The new leader, elected in a Friday afternoon coup, appears to have lost his six followers in only four days. No Senate Republican on the committee posed a question to beleaguered Office of Higher Education Executive Director Timothy Larson, a Democrat and former member of the Senate.

Larson’s appearance was scheduled to coincide with the launch of the state’s scheme to require abandoned Stone Academy students to waive all rights of recovery in exchange for small recoveries based on the flawed audit of their transcripts.

There are only a dozen Senate Republicans. Three of them serve on the 53 member budget committee. Two of the three backed Harding in his quiet campaign to oust Kelly. It should not have required much effort to arrange for one or both of Harding’s supporters to raise the issues their new leader posed in his defiant there’s-a-new-sheriff-in-town statement.

Bravado married to silence is not the way forward to success.

Published February 20, 2024.

Three state agencies are marking the first anniversary of the closing of Stone Academy by escalating their war on the more than 1,000 students who were locked out of their classes.. The for-profit nursing school students did not receive a traditional teach-out to allow them to complete the courses they had paid for. Their plight has only worsened in the year that followed.

A state judge intervened on behalf of the students Friday by enjoining the Office of Higher Education (OHE), the Department of Public Health (DPH) and the Office of Attorney General from proceeding with a scheme that would required students to waive their rights in exchange for reimbursement payments that did not include courses arbitrarily delated from their transcripts during an audit paid for and overseen by OHE and influenced by DPH.

The injunction follows weeks of fruitless attempts by lawyers representing students to persuade lawyers for the state to refrain from limiting students’ rights of recovery of the damages they suffered in the long mess. Lawyers for the students explained in their motion for an emergency injunction wrote:

At issue is the State’s demand that hundreds of former Stone Academy Students sign a
waiver of rights against the State in exchange for payment of just a small fraction of the damages
they incurred because of the bad conduct of both the Stone Academy Defendants and the
Connecticut’s Office of Higher Education and Department of Public Health. The State, and its
lawyers, should know better than to seek such a waiver of rights from persons, without them
having advice of counsel and particularly where, as here, the State has an obvious conflict of
interest.

Legislators sympathetic to the students will have an opportunity to inquire why OHE supports harming students when the agency’s leader, Timothy Larson, appears before the Appropriations Committee Tuesday to discuss its funding in Governor Ned Lamont’s budget proposal.

Published February 16, 2024.

Senate Republicans forced their leader, Kevin Kelly, to resign Friday and replaced him with Stephen Harding, a first term member of the upper chamber from the 30th District, Daily Ructions has learned. In a curious decision, Kelly made plea for his colleagues’ support and they declined to give it to him in a stunning rebuke.

The move came three weeks after Kelly fired controversial chief of staff John Healey a year after hiring him. Johnny Angel, as he is known from a video introduced at a federal criminal trial, may return to the job he lost. That would be good news for Speaker Matt Ritter, his top staff members and some local golf courses.

Several of the 12 members of the dwindling Senate Republican caucus face ferocious challenges in this year’s November election. Fractures among the diminishing Republicans, which includes Q-Anon supporter Eric Berthel, will make holding those seats more difficult.

One of the short-term winners today may be the caucus’s inveterate pot stirrer, Heather Somers. The Groton Republican is talented at fomenting dissent but not in building the trust of her colleagues. There can be no other explanation for Republican senators passing over Somers, in her fourth term, for a first term member who previously served in the House.

Senate Republicans are straining to put a brave face on the upheaval they sowed. Harding and his six supporters may soon discover that five members of a dozen member laughingstock caucus can make nearly as much trouble as the other seven.

Jack Shannon remains.

Published February 16, 2024.

Martin “Bo” Burke has departed this world at 83 years old. We are all in his debt.

The Vernon Democrat may have been the most consequential one-term legislator to serve in the state House of Representatives. In 1975, Bo was the driving force behind the drafting and passage of the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). He was a freshman from Vernon, winning the 56th House District in the 1974 Watergate election that saw Democrats win 118 of the lower chamber’s 151 seats.

Ella Grasso, also elected in 1974, brought a reforming spirit to the governor’s office. She had served three terms as secretary of the state (1959-1971) and was a natural ally of open government supporters, including the freshman from Vernon.

For nearly 50 years, Bo has been recognized as the author of the FOIA. The legislature was thinly staffed in 1975 compared to what it has become. A lawmaker had to immerse himself in the task of drawing legislation, especially a bill creating new rights and the mechanism to enforce them. Bo Burke, a master of details, met his moment. Grasso signed the bill during the first year in office. It was among her most enduring accomplishments.

Requiring most local and state government public meetings to be open to the public was not Connecticut’s tradition–or that of any other state. Access to government documents was limited–often at the sufferance of appointed and elected public officials.

Bo Burke changed that 49 years ago. Connecticut’s FOIA, the first and most sweeping of its kind, became a model for the nation and then, as freedom defeated servitude with the fall of the Soviet Union, an inspiration and guide to hundreds of millions of people around the world as they sought to secure their freedom under the rule of law. Connecticut’s law showed them the way forward.

Bo declined to seek a second term in 1976 because the legislature can be difficult to balance with a law practice and life with a young family.

Politicians can spend decades in elected office and never do more than dutifully cast roll call votes and raise money. Few in their first of two years in office craft, guide, and see signed into law legislation that becomes an indispensable to creating and sustaining free societies in a modern world.

Bo’s interest in the FOIA never diminished. He would often contact journalists to discuss attempts by governors and legislators to weaken the public’s right to know how government conducted its business. His knowledge encompassed not only the spirit of the law but also its fluid details. His passion for its purpose and dismay at the attacks it stirred among a string of hostile governors and legislators never flagged.

A decade after Bo left office, voters of the 56th House District elected Joe Courtney to represent them. He served for four terms and decided not to seek a fifth in 1994. Twelve years later, Bo was delighted when his friend and colleague in overseeing Vernon’s legal affairs was elected to Congress from the state’s 2nd District.

Later this month, Joe Courtney will introduce a tribute to Martin “Bo” Burke into the Congressional Record.

Published February 14, 2024.

The Courant’s Ed Mahony reports on another stunning development in the saga of turmoil in the Division of Public Defender Services. Chief Public Defender TaShun Bowden-Lewis is testing the capacity for surprise of Division employees, the Public Defender Services Commission and the public.

Bowden-Lewis, according to The Courant, “instructed an information technology staffer to download confidential email and possibly other files from computers used by two senior lawyers who are considered to be among her critics.” When agency IT director Greg Dion received an alert that security protections had been overridden, he notified the two senior lawyers whose email accounts had been breached. Bowden-Lewis and director of Human Resources Paula Lohr suspended Dion and escorted him out of the agency’s Farmington Avenue office, according to Mahony.

The head of a state agency engaging in such conduct will send tremors through state government if there are not immediate repercussions.

The incident prompted commission chairman Richard Palmer, a retired member of the Supreme Court, to issue another statement expressing dismay and hinting at action. Palmer wrote:

“The Commission and I were recently informed that Mr. Dion has been suspended with pay by the Chief Public Defender, who neither notified nor consulted the Commission prior to taking this action or anytime thereafter. I do know, however, that Mr. Dion is very highly regarded as an accomplished member of the Division’s Management Team, and I have asked the Chief Public Defender to provide me immediately with answers to a number of serious questions I have regarding her action against him. But from what I have already learned about Mr. Dion’s suspension and the reasons for it, I’m very concerned about the propriety of that action as I understand that the conduct that resulted in Mr. Dion’s suspension was intended merely to ensure the security and integrity of the Division’s IT system for the protection of private, confidential, and privileged communications of two senior Division attorneys, Deborah Del Prete Sullivan, Legal Counsel, and Joseph Lopez, Director of the Complex Litigation Unit, whose email accounts were accessed without their knowledge or consent. I also note that both Attorney Sullivan and Attorney Lopez have worked cooperatively with the Commission, in the best interests of the Division, since the Commission’s appointment nearly a year ago. For now, I can add only that I have been in contact with the other members of the Commission, and we may well call a special meeting of the Commission in the very near future to address this issue.”

Greg Dion told Bruno Matarazzo Jr., of the Republican American, “I’m disappointed this happened to me for doing the right thing and reporting something that compromised the integrity of the systems and the agency,” Dion also expressed dismay that a subordinate used their position to get access to email accounts that should not have been breached.

A special meeting of the Commission would come on the heels of Tuesday’s regularly scheduled February meeting. That meeting is said to have included raised voices when the Commission met in executive session behind closed doors. The doors may have been closed but they are not soundproof.

Published February 8, 2024.

Governor Ned Lamont will need to adjust his budget proposal. The State Supreme Court on Tuesday affirmed a 2021 trial court decision awarding a Bristol family $34 million in damages arising out a negligent 2014 fertility procedure.

Aaron and Jean-Marie Monroe-Lynch learned in 2014 that they were pregnant with twins after a fertility procedure at UConn Health. Tragedy followed when the twins were born and discovered to have been infected with Cytomegalovirus (CMV). Shay was born dead. Her brother Joshua was born severe birth defects, including catastrophic neurological and developmental disabilities. Joshua requires constant care.

Writing for a unanimous court, Justice Joan Alexander noted in her opinion excoriating UConn Health’s fertility program, “it is clear that the state is both the party best equipped to avoid mishaps of this sort and the party best positioned to absorb and spread the costs of Joshua’s lifelong care. See Doe v. Cochran, supra, 332 Conn. 369. With respect to avoiding the harm, the state offers a highly specialized medical service that poses particular risks best known to the state and most efficiently pre- vented by it. The state regularly shepherds inexperi- enced and medically unsophisticated patients through the complex process of assisted reproduction. It would have required little effort and even less financial cost for Benadiva or a member of his staff to confirm the CMV status of the donor and to counsel Jean-Marie to select a different donor or, at least, to obtain her informed consent to be certain that she fully understood the serious risks of going forward under the circumstances.”

The plaintiffs were represented by the Walsh Woodard law firm located in West Hartford.  The case was tried by Attorneys Michael Walsh, Karolina Dowd, and Caitlyn Malcynsky.  After the trial, the case was handled by Attorney Linc Woodard.  The appeal was handled by Attorney James Healy.  

The Superior Court decision by Judge Mark Taylor and the emphatic unanimous high court opinion should prompt a review by the legislature on how the fourth branch of government, the University of Connecticut, handles claims against it: poorly. It should no longer be allowed to act as its own claims adjuster. UConn and the public would benefit from an independent review board that can assess claims and steer them to a resolution when the facts merit it.

UConn’s arrogance was on display in today’s fertility case and also in former UConn men’s basketball coach Kevin Ollie’s claim for breach of contract and racial discrimination. UConn paid $15 million to Ollie, including $3.9 million to resolve his racism claim against the state’s premier public university.

This year’s UConn budget did not include an allocation sufficient to pay the medical malpractice claim, though observers were skeptical of its appeal strategy. The legislature will have to find the money and ought to ask probing questions on what steps UConn took to engage in meaningful settlement negotiations with both the Monroe-Lynch family and Ollie.

Published February 6, 2024.

That didn’t take long. Farmington Republican John Healey will no longer serve a chief of staff to the Senate Republican Office. Veteran Republican Gary DeFilippo, former Department of Motor Vehicles commissioner in the Rowland and Rell administrations, will fill the vacancy as the dozen members of the minority caucus brace themselves for some serious headwinds.

Healey, seen first and foremost as a loyalist to popular New Britain Mayor Erin Stewart, has been perceived as having Stewart’s interests as much in mind as the caucus’s, which are urgent. Stewart, re-elected to a sixth term in November, has not thrived in state party politics. She dropped her 2018 bid for governor on the eve of the state convention to make a late run at the second spot on the ticket. Stewart lost the lieutenant governor primary to Southington Republican Joe Markley.

Healey came into public view in May 2013 when he was revealed on a FBI recording as carrying illicit cash from then-House Republican Leader Lawrence Cafero’s office to a law enforcement co-operator who had put the money in Cafero’s office refrigerator. Cafero had Healey, who he dubbed Johnny Angel, take the money to FBI informant Raymond Soucy. Neither Cafero nor Healey notified law enforcement authorities of the bribery attempt.

Veteran staffer Jack Shannon remains.

The regular session of the legislature begins Wednesday.